Penguin Random House Sues Florida School Over Book Bans
How do you feel about the expanding bans on learning materials?
Updated May 19, 2023
- Penguin Random House, the largest U.S. publisher, sued a Flordia county school board for banning and restricting access to books. The lawsuit, PEN America v. Book Bans, alleges that banning the books in school libraries violates constitutional rights to free speech and equal protection under the law.
- The publisher claims that school officials are acting in defiance of existing policies that disproporionately impact books addressing racism and LGBTQIA+ relationships.
Updated May 11, 2023
- In his ongoing attack on "woke indoctrination" in education, Florida's Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis is expanding his influence on what is taught in the state's public schools.
- Education officials have rejected 66 of 101 submitted social studies textbooks, many of which had to make revisions requested by the state before getting approved. Initially only 19 books were approved because the rest of the submissions did not align with Florida law and contained information about controversial political, social, and racial topics.
- In one of the textbooks, references to the murder of George Floyd and the Black Lives Matter movement were removed. In another submission, the term "social justice issues" was changed to "key principles."
- The list of rejected materials included books on U.S. history and the Holocaust, but officials have only offered vague justification for the rejections, stating that the books did not meet state standards.
- Florida Democratic Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz said:
"DeSantis and extreme MAGA Republicans are bent on dumbing down America's education system and silencing Black voices."
- Defending the choices, Florida Education Commissioner Manny Diaz Jr. said:
"To uphold our exceptional standards, we must ensure our students and teachers have the highest quality materials available – materials that focus on historical facts and are free from inaccuracies or ideological rhetoric."
Updated February 14, 2023
- The non-profit College Board, the testing organization that created the African American studies course that DeSantis banned from Florida high schools, accused the state Education Department of “slander” and spreading misinformation about the course for political gain.
- College Board said,
“We deeply regret not immediately denouncing the Florida Department of Education’s slander, magnified by the DeSantis administration’s subsequent comments, that African American Studies ‘lacks educational value. Our failure to raise our voice betrayed Black scholars everywhere and those who have long toiled to build this remarkable field.”
What's the story?
- Florida Gov. Ron Desantis (R) has banned a new advanced African American high school history course as part of the “Stop WOKE” act that regulates and limits how race and gender are taught in state schools.
- Under DeSantis, Florida has banned the teaching of critical race theory.
What is the course?
- The course is part of a pilot program by the US College Board which will be taught in 60 secondary schools across the country.
- The course was designed to cover over 400 years of African American history, literature, geography, and politics.
What does the DeSantis Administration Say?
- Governor Ron DeSantis' administration said the proposed course
"[L]acks educational value and is contrary to Florida law."
- DeSantis and his officials have not specified which Florida law the course breaks.
- The Florida Department of Education described its intention to block the course on January 12th. DeSantis officially banned the course in a letter from the state education department to the College Board, writing:
"In Florida, we are taking a stand against the state-sanctioned racism that is critical race theory."
What are the Criticisms?
- The decision has been met with condemnation from the National Parents Union who consider the decision an attack on all BIPOC communities, and an example of censorship and historical erasure.
- Senator Shevrin Jones (D-FL) criticized the ban, asking why European History courses were still being taught.
- The ban is the newest legal attack on discussions about race, gender, sex, and critical theory in schools in the state.
Do you want to prevent the ban from spreading to other states? How do you feel about the ban?
—Emma Kansiz
(Photo Credit: Twitter)
The Latest
-
IT: Battles between students and police intensify, and... 💻 Should we regulate AI access to our private data?Welcome to Thursday, May 2nd, listeners... The battle between protesters and police intensifies on college campuses across the read more...
-
Should U.S. Implement Laws Protecting Private Data from AI Access?Artificial intelligence is rapidly integrating into our everyday lives, transforming the way we work, live, and interact with read more... Artificial Intelligence
-
Protests Grow Nationwide as Students Demand Divestment From IsraelUpdated May 1, 2024, 11:00 a.m. EST The battle between protesters and police has intensified on college campuses across the read more... Advocacy
-
IT: Rumors spread about ICC charging Israel with war crimes, and... Should states disqualify Trump?Welcome to Tuesday, April 30th, friends... Rumors spread that the International Criminal Court could issue arrest warrants for read more...
DeSantis is a racist. It's just that simple. He should not be intruding in the educational curriculum especially when the class is college level advanced placement. I'm certain he is banning because he cannot understand it himself.
Republicanism = Nazism
If they can keep you ignorant,and control how and who you can vote for, then they control you.
A lot of Americans died to prevent this Nazism from happening in the past.
If the course was to be taught right it would cover the history of the Democrats around the Civil War and the aftermath like the poll tax and the DEMOCRATIC JIM CROW LAWS. It would cover George Wallace and the fights of the Democratic Party toward Dr Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. and the civil rights movement.
Of course there will be no mention of this in the history of Black peoples.
Shows a complete ignorance of history & how it's taught, or else ignoring his Ivy League education to play partisan politics to achieve political goals by appealing to negative emotions.
K-12 history is usually taught as timelines while college level looks at the various interpretations of those timelines and comparing differences. A few AP classes may be taught in some but not all schools for high performing students to do college work while in high school and gain college credit by taking AP tests at the completion of the course. I did this in high school to spend less time (and money) in college by skipping a semester or year as I had earned my freshman credit hours while still in high school. Not all schools offer this. I attended 2 different school systems growing up as my father moved us in order to live in a school system offering AP classes, Few surrounding city school systems even offered this.
DeSantis is well aware of this and manipulating the electorate that is unfamiliar with how the education system operates.
Oh my yes, he is taking a stand alright. He has neon Swastikas on the top of tall buildings in the North of Florida and in the South. We need to pass a law against the display of hate symbols like that in America. To many Americans of all races died fighting that war to stop Hitler and his terrible hate of the Jews. I'm sure that the governor is aware of it, they are NEON, you can't miss them! Well, then again maybe he attended schools that took such histories OUT OF THEIR CURRICULUM!!!!!!
THIS is a lie!! Shame on causes.com!!!!!
The course criticism by Gov DeSantis is NOT about teaching African American history. The course is LOADED w/LEFT-WING PROPAGANDA about closing prisons, trans & queer theory, "intersectionality",etc.
DeSantis is FOR teaching the history of SLAVERY, Civil War, Reconstruction, Jim Crow, segregation, the Covil Rights movement, etc. He favors teaching HISTORY RATHER THAN PROPAGANDA.
THIS SITE promotes propaganda& the ignorance of those participating in this survey is evidence of NOT knowing the full story. Be better!
Yeah, nothing spells "progress" like disallowing people to read and learn.
I find it interesting that smiley faces aren't available on some of the questions being offered. It looks like differing opinions are not wanted. As far as the books, maybe the school systems don't think the books are appropriate.
How can opinions be formulated with out having the ability to review all material?
From a friend that is a teacher
ALL books are valuable!
Desantis is a racist and a fascist. Banning books is following Hitler. What's next? Building bonfires to burn books? History is an important part of education. Choosing to ignore what has already happened is going to result in an undereducated student population. Furthermore it is trampling on the rights of the groups that are being excluded. This should and cannot spread to other states.
Again causes cannot even put a happy face for a selection on this.
Perfect move to slap the Democrats immorality in the face.
Banning books....what books? Banning who from reading them? Causes just continues to stir the pot of hare!
i can't tell you how happy it makes me that peguin is suing florida. i love it.
How dare you take away the smiley face! CRT is causing irreparable harm to the African-American people. It victimizes them and make them feel entitled, discourages them to work for a living and seek higher education. The worst thing is that it causes division and makes that divide in the American people worse than ever before. That is how some in our government seek to control us. They sow hatred between the races so we focus on each other instead of seeing the freedoms that are being taken away from us. Wake up people!
There may be some materials that should not be in school libraries. But the politicians should not be the ones deciding what should or should not be. I do not have the answer myself but I believe in the parents of our children to allow them to choose their reading material.
They will find and read everything that is banned just because it has been banned.
The first thing fascists do is come for books, education and voter suppression. When are Democrats going to wake up and call Republicans the fascists they are.
I agree with nothing that Marjorie Greene says except that it is time for the red and blue states to separate into two countries
Sexual education should take place in the home. Parents are the best judge as to when their children are ready to learn about sexual relations. Parents have the given responsibility to train their children and it should be their choice, not the choice of the librarian or school teacher, as to which teaching materials are used. There is a vast difference in moral values among families and the government-run schools, and respect should be given to our homes. Government should not be indoctrinating our children with immoral ideology. Schools need to return to reading, writing, and arithmetic.
Only the voluntarily blind and involuntarily undereducated could support dumbing down what used to be one of the world's the academic pinnacles. Thanks for nothing, De Stupid.
Why would education be stifled?
Hummmm
Management of schools should be 100% handled by parents and school administrators. Federal and state government should be told to stay out of it.
Again, where is my smiley face option?? All you offer is the apathy and frowny faces!! They are not banning books you idiots, they are restricting to age appropriate materials. You don't need to teach a 7 year old how to suck cock or play with themselves.
i thought we moved past the banning of books , books r for learning and to think about differrnt views and learrning about actual history and other peoples cultures these republicans need too be voted out of office we dont need to have our government leaders telling us what is rright and what isnt unless its meant to stop the spreading of hate and ignorance
How about we ban ignorant butt holes? This guy is going to have a very short shelf life. Well, he will get the kkk vote.
Back to Jim Crow days for all the backward, heartless repubs who want to tax the poor and give it to their big money "supporters" those who bribe Congress to get more money for nothing.!