Should Federal Antitrust Law Apply to Health Insurance? (H.R. 372)
Do you support or oppose this bill?
What is H.R. 372?
(Updated May 10, 2020)
This bill would bring the health and dental insurance industry under compliance with federal antitrust laws. Under current law (through the McCarran-Ferguson Act) health insurance providers are exempted from federal antitrust laws. These laws are in place to prevent unfair business practices like collusion, bid rigging, price fixing, and other things that reduce competition, lead to monopolies, and harm consumers.
Nothing in this bill would prevent states from maintaining and enforcing their own insurance regulations, antitrust laws, and consumer protections as they currently do.
Life insurance, property and casualty insurance, or other portions of the insurance industry would be completely unaffected by this legislation.
Argument in favor
Health insurance companies shouldn’t be exempt from antitrust laws that would otherwise punish them for colluding and price fixing -- actions that hurt consumers and enrich insurers.
Argument opposed
By not subjecting them to antitrust law, the status quo enables health insurance companies to provide better service to consumers. It’d be foolish to end the exemption.
Impact
Anyone who needs health care, health care providers, insurance companies offering health and/or dental coverage, federal agencies that investigate and prosecute antitrust violations.
Cost of H.R. 372
A CBO cost estimate is unavailable.
Additional Info
In-Depth: When he introduced this bill during the 114th Congress, sponsoring Rep. Paul Gosar (R-AZ) blasted the health insurance industry for becoming “one of the least transparent and most anti-competitive industries in the United States.” He also added that “hospitals, doctors and patients alike all benefit when health insurers compete to provide quality coverage.”
Rep. Gosar has introduced similar versions of this bill in recent years, with a version stalling in a House committee in 2011 during the 112th Congress, and another in 2013 during the 113th Congress. The version from the 114th Congress also stalled in committee.
This legislation has the support of 20 cosponsors in the House all of whom are Republicans. It was reported by the House Judiciary Committee favorably without a recorded vote..
Of Note: The Congressional Budget Office analyzed related legislation in 2009, and found that any effect on health care premiums would be small. Meanwhile, the likelihood of an increase or decrease in premiums was difficult to determine.
Kaiser Health News published an article in 2010, estimating that eliminating the antitrust law exemption could increase the number of lawsuits. However, they found that because health insurers may need to change the way they do business, consumers would benefit.
For its part, the primary regulator of the health insurance industry — the Federal Trade Commission — hasn’t directly weighed in on the existing antitrust exemption. But, it has stated that:
“Competition in health care markets benefits consumers because it helps contain costs, improve quality, and encourage innovation.”Media:
- Sponsoring Rep. Paul Gosar (R-AZ) Press Release
- DickinsonWright
- American Dental Association (In Favor)
- American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons (In Favor - Previous Version)
- Kaiser Health News (Context)
-
U.S. News and World Report (Context - In Favor)
Summary by Eric Revell
(Photo Credit: Flickr user CarbonNYC)
The Latest
-
IT: Trump's 2016 'deny, deny, deny' campaign strategy, and... How can you help the civilians of Ukraine?Welcome to Wednesday, May 8th, weekenders... As Trump's hush money trial enters it's third week, the 2016 campaign strategy of read more...
-
How To Help Civilians in UkraineHeavy shelling and fighting have caused widespread death, destruction of homes and businesses, and severely damaged read more... Public Safety
-
The Latest: Israel Evacuates Rafah, Palestinian Place of RefugeUpdated May 6, 2024, 12:00 p.m. EST The Israeli military is telling residents of Gaza who have sought shelter in Rafah to read more... Israel
-
Trump Hush Money Trial Enters Third Week, Strategy to ‘Deny, Deny, Deny’Updated May 6, 2024, 11:00 a.m. EST The criminal trial to determine whether Trump is guilty of falsifying records to cover up a read more... Law Enforcement