{"bills":[{"photos":{"featured":"https://assets.causes.com/bill/photo/hr372-115/featured_competitive-health-insurance-reform-act-of-2017-1489965367.jpg","featured_large":"https://assets.causes.com/bill/photo/hr372-115/featured_large_competitive-health-insurance-reform-act-of-2017-1489965367.jpg","shareable":"https://n.causes.com/share-images/bills/hr372-115.png"},"introduced_on":"2017-01-09","title_override":"Should Federal Antitrust Law Apply to Health Insurance?","summary_override":"

This bill would bring the health and dental insurance industry under compliance with federal antitrust laws. Under current law (through the McCarran-Ferguson Act) health insurance providers are exempted from federal antitrust laws. These laws are in place to prevent unfair business practices like collusion, bid rigging, price fixing, and other things that reduce competition, lead to monopolies, and harm consumers.

Nothing in this bill would prevent states from maintaining and enforcing their own insurance regulations, antitrust laws, and consumer protections as they currently do.

Life insurance, property and casualty insurance, or other portions of the insurance industry would be completely unaffected by this legislation.

","official_title":"To restore the application of the Federal antitrust laws to the business of health insurance to protect competition and consumers.","short_title":"Competitive Health Insurance Reform Act of 2017","popular_title":null,"short_summary":"(This measure has not been amended since it was reported to the House on March 15, 2017. The summary of that version is repeated here.)\n\nCompetitive Health Insurance Reform Act of 2017\n\n(Sec. 2) This bill amends the McCarran-Ferguson Act to declare that nothing in that Act modifies, impairs, or supersedes the operation of antitrust laws with respect to the business of health insurance, including the business of dental insurance. This declaration does not apply to a contract, combination, or conspiracy to: (1) collect, compile, or disseminate historical loss data; (2) determine a loss development factor for historical loss data; (3) perform actuarial services if the collaboration does not involve a restraint of trade; or (4) develop or disseminate a standard insurance policy form if adherence to the form is not required.\n\nProhibitions against unfair methods of competition apply to the business of health insurance without regard to whether the business is for profit.","summarized":true,"cost":null,"cost_commentary":"A CBO cost estimate is unavailable.","impact":"Anyone who needs health care, health care providers, insurance companies offering health and/or dental coverage, federal agencies that investigate and prosecute antitrust violations.","argument_for":"Health insurance companies shouldn’t be exempt from antitrust laws that would otherwise punish them for colluding and price fixing -- actions that hurt consumers and enrich insurers.","argument_against":"By not subjecting them to antitrust law, the status quo enables health insurance companies to provide better service to consumers. It’d be foolish to end the exemption.","bill_type":"hr","published":true,"type":"FederalBill","id":"hr372-115","bill_id":"hr372-115","formal_id":"H.R. 372","chamber":"house","congress":115,"last_action_at":"2017-03-23T00:00:00.000Z","active":true,"enacted":false,"enacted_at":null,"vetoed":false,"last_vote_at":"2017-03-22T17:53:33.000Z","debated_on":null,"congress_url":"https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th/house-bill/372","plain_text_url":"https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-115hr372ih/html/BILLS-115hr372ih.htm","shareable_image_url":"https://n.causes.com/share-images/bills/hr372-115.png","congress_full_text_url":"https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th/house-bill/372/text","is_current_congress":false,"last_version_on":"2017-01-09","related_bill_ids":["hr1072-115","s222-115","hres209-115"],"progress":"Passed House","house_passage_result":true,"senate_passage_result":false,"position_count":1455,"committees":[{"name":"Committee on the Judiciary","chamber":"house","committee_id":"HSJU","subcommittee":false},{"name":"Antitrust, Commercial and Administrative Law","chamber":"house","committee_id":"HSJU05","subcommittee":true},{"name":"Committee on the Judiciary","chamber":"senate","committee_id":"SSJU","subcommittee":false}],"links":{"rollCalls":"/api/roll_calls?bill_id=hr372-115","details":"/api/bills/hr372-115/details","sharingMessage":"/api/sharing_messages/hr372-115","positionsFor":"/api/bills/hr372-115/positions/for","positionsAgainst":"/api/bills/hr372-115/positions/against"},"upcoming":false,"cosponsors_count":20,"slug":"hr372-115-competitive-health-insurance-reform-act-of-2017","latest_chamber_votes_id":"hr372-115","official_url":null,"target_video":true,"following":false,"vote_count":18521,"yea_vote_count":17196,"nay_vote_count":1282,"passed_house":true,"passed_senate":false,"vote_id":null,"my_position_id":null,"topic_ids":["government","financial-markets","health"],"issue_ids":["consumer-safety","insurance","federal-agencies","government","financial-markets","health"],"sponsor_id":406}],"votes":[],"issues":[{"id":"consumer-safety","name":"Consumer Safety","slug":"consumer-safety","description":"Vote on the latest federal legislation regarding consumer safety. Make your voice heard about the issues you care about. \r\n","page_title":"Consumer Safety Legislation - Vote on Bills, Stay informed, Hold Your Reps Accountable","icons":{"black":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/consumer-safety/black_consumer-safety-1429042054.svg","grey":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/consumer-safety/grey_consumer-safety-1429042054.svg","white":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/consumer-safety/white_consumer-safety-1429042054.svg"},"cover_image_url":null,"is_following":false},{"id":"insurance","name":"Insurance","slug":"insurance","description":"Vote on the latest federal legislation regarding Insurance. Make your voice heard about the issues you care about. \r\n","page_title":"Insurance Legislation - Vote on Bills, Stay informed, Hold Your Reps Accountable","icons":{"black":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/insurance/black_insurance-1429042051.svg","grey":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/insurance/grey_insurance-1429042051.svg","white":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/insurance/white_insurance-1429042051.svg"},"cover_image_url":null,"is_following":false},{"id":"federal-agencies","name":"Federal Agencies","slug":"federal-agencies","description":"Vote on the latest federal legislation regarding Federal Agencies. Make your voice heard about the issues you care about. \r\n","page_title":"Federal Agencies Legislation - Vote on Bills, Stay informed, Hold Your Reps Accountable","icons":{"black":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/federal-agencies/black_federal-agencies-1429042054.svg","grey":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/federal-agencies/grey_federal-agencies-1429042054.svg","white":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/federal-agencies/white_federal-agencies-1429042054.svg"},"cover_image_url":null,"is_following":false},{"id":"government","name":"Government","slug":"government","description":"Federal legislation related to the operations of the US Federal Government. Bills can encompass government administration, regulation of political parties, the US postal service, US territories and public contracts.","page_title":"US Government - Federal legislation - Vote on Bills, Stay informed, Hold Your Reps Accountable","icons":{"black":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/government/black_government-1453508811.svg","grey":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/government/grey_government-1453508811.svg","white":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/government/white_government-1453508811.svg"},"cover_image_url":null,"is_following":false},{"id":"financial-markets","name":"Financial Markets","slug":"financial-markets","description":"Regulations for the US financial Markets - including Banking, Securities, Insurance, Currency and the Credit Markets. Legislation can also cover foreign loans, corporations and debt.","page_title":"Federal legislation related to regulating US financial markets and the US Currency - Vote on Bills, Stay informed, Hold Your Reps Accountable","icons":{"black":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/financial-markets/black_financial-markets-1429042042.svg","grey":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/financial-markets/grey_financial-markets-1429042042.svg","white":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/financial-markets/white_financial-markets-1429042042.svg"},"cover_image_url":null,"is_following":false},{"id":"health","name":"Health","slug":"health","description":"Federal legislation around Health, encompassing: the Affordable Care Act, Medicare, Research into diseases (Cancer, HIV/Aids, Ebola), Drug safety, Hospital care and prescription drugs.","page_title":"Health Related US Federal legislation, including Medicare, ACA, and research - Vote on Bills, Stay informed, Hold Your Reps Accountable","icons":{"black":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/health/black_health-1429042037.svg","grey":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/health/grey_health-1429042037.svg","white":"https://assets.causes.com/issue/icon/health/white_health-1429042037.svg"},"cover_image_url":null,"is_following":false}],"users":[{"name":"Julie ","vote_count":70,"photos":{"large":"https://graph.facebook.com/10154115759461384/picture?width=150&height=150","small":"https://graph.facebook.com/10154115759461384/picture?width=75&height=75","tiny":"https://graph.facebook.com/10154115759461384/picture?width=20&height=20","facebook":"https://graph.facebook.com/10154115759461384/picture"},"links":{"following":"/api/users/4mKKQEqm/following","followers":"/api/users/4mKKQEqm/followers"},"about_me":null,"twitter_id":null,"facebook_id":null,"youtube_id":null,"google_plus_id":null,"website":null,"slug":null,"issue_count":29,"is_following":null,"influence_score":30,"influence_level":10,"follower_count":1,"following_count":4,"position_count":47,"id":"4mKKQEqm","partner_id":null},{"name":"Tafinzer","vote_count":291,"photos":{"large":"https://assets.causes.com/user/avatar/yWjEybY9/large_ywjeyby9-1487174556.jpg","small":"https://assets.causes.com/user/avatar/yWjEybY9/small_ywjeyby9-1487174556.jpg","tiny":"https://assets.causes.com/user/avatar/yWjEybY9/tiny_ywjeyby9-1487174556.jpg"},"links":{"following":"/api/users/yWjEybY9/following","followers":"/api/users/yWjEybY9/followers"},"about_me":"Just a fellow traveler bumping along trying to get through it all","twitter_id":"@tafinzer","facebook_id":null,"youtube_id":null,"google_plus_id":null,"website":"","slug":"tafinzer","issue_count":131,"is_following":null,"influence_score":31650,"influence_level":40,"follower_count":649,"following_count":16650,"position_count":55,"id":"yWjEybY9","partner_id":null}],"bill_position":{"flagged":false,"id":"aa440c0e-f806-4725-ac44-fd26a8cdc393","argument_for":"I suspect there is fine print not in the summary. On its face, I support transparency. If an insurer is acting in the consumers's best interest, they shouldn't have a concern about showing their practices. ","argument_against":null,"show_argument_for":true,"show_argument_against":false,"upvote_count":1,"upvotes_for_count":1,"upvotes_against_count":null,"has_upvoted":false,"endorsement_count":1,"links":{"self":"https://www.causes.com/positions/aa440c0e-f806-4725-ac44-fd26a8cdc393"},"body":"I suspect there is fine print not in the summary. On its face, I support transparency. If an insurer is acting in the consumers's best interest, they shouldn't have a concern about showing their practices. ","stance":"yea","created_at":"2017-03-20T16:08:53.336Z","shareable_image_url":"https://n.causes.com/share-images/positions/aa440c0e-f806-4725-ac44-fd26a8cdc393.png","note_color":null,"note_text":null,"bill_id":"hr372-115","user_id":"4mKKQEqm","endorser_ids":["yWjEybY9"]}}

Like Causes?

Julie

Should Federal Antitrust Law Apply to Health Insurance?