Rose Russell Clifford
Rose Russell Clifford

They are illegal sorry they break the law coming to the US if we did it to their country we would be jailed or even thrown out the same day. When in Rome !

John Tripp Sheffield
John Tripp Sheffield
  • Rose Russell Clifford

That's an invalid argument Dayna. There was no government & no laws here when Europeans first arrived. And how do you know Rose's ancestors had any involvement anyway??
That's just cliched liberal bs coming out of your backside, trying to make a moot point.

Steinar Andersen
Steinar Andersen
  • Rose Russell Clifford

John, well said.

Oliver Austin
Oliver Austin
  • Rose Russell Clifford

I'm not American, but the slaughter of millions of native Americans by both Europeans and Americans following the constitution amounts to genocide. Regardless of whether there was 'a government or laws', the American dream realised in the great 'manifest destiny' and the quasi-eradication of a civilised peoples is equivalent to a systematic re-population of the Americas.

David Polk
David Polk
  • Rose Russell Clifford

yes most definately, if their laws said we could not, but they had no law against us coming over

Rude Calderon
Rude Calderon
  • Rose Russell Clifford

There were respected agreements within Native American nations, here in Mexico, in Peru, they just weren't European laws. Come on you didn't know that, or are you in historical denial?

Robi Schwab
Robi Schwab
  • Rose Russell Clifford

John Tripp Sheffield. What are you trying to prove with your idiotic statement regarding Dayna McCamley's comment. You're a liar and you KNOW that. God's Ten Commandments were very well in place AND known by everyone during America's genocide of the Native Poeple there. So DON'T come and try to blame the non existing American Law for your ancestors' ungodly sadistic behavior toward these poor innocent Native Americans. Just what kind of a human being ARE you trying to justify MURDER and then...

John Tripp Sheffield. What are you trying to prove with your idiotic statement regarding Dayna McCamley's comment. You're a liar and you KNOW that. God's Ten Commandments were very well in place AND known by everyone during America's genocide of the Native Poeple there. So DON'T come and try to blame the non existing American Law for your ancestors' ungodly sadistic behavior toward these poor innocent Native Americans. Just what kind of a human being ARE you trying to justify MURDER and then on top of that try to convince people that it's the correct thing to do.

Robi Schwab
Robi Schwab
  • Rose Russell Clifford

So what's your point. Because THEIR laws allowed you to move to their country this means you can slaughter them?

Jim Shott
Jim Shott
  • Rose Russell Clifford

Dayna, my grandparents immigrated legally and had nothing to do with genocide of the natives nor slavery. But I get blamed for both due to being a Caucasian. Is THAT right?

Alexandra Seelig
Alexandra Seelig

I am not racist or against immigrants, no matter how they come here. But the point is, it's a factual statement. If you immigrate illegally, you are an illegal immigrant. 'Undocumented' implies that our government has somehow lapsed in not noticing them--this is not the point. We do allow immigrants, but they have to go through a process. Skipping the line is not okay and avoiding a factual and correct term in order to avoid stepping on toes is condoning what they are doing, which is...

I am not racist or against immigrants, no matter how they come here. But the point is, it's a factual statement. If you immigrate illegally, you are an illegal immigrant. 'Undocumented' implies that our government has somehow lapsed in not noticing them--this is not the point. We do allow immigrants, but they have to go through a process. Skipping the line is not okay and avoiding a factual and correct term in order to avoid stepping on toes is condoning what they are doing, which is breaking the law.

If someone runs a red light, then yes, they are driving illegally. But we don't call them an illegal driver because that doesn't describe a constant situation or state. If someone doesn't have a driver's license, then they are an illegal driver because they are in a state of illegality, not just a one-time offender. Illegal immigrants live in America illegally and are likewise in a state of illegality. We aren't saying the humans are illegal--being a human is always legal. However, they are illegal immigrants.

This petition just spotlights a major issue in American culture right now. Our need to be uber-PC might avoid stepping on a few toes right now but ultimately will devastate our morals in the long run. Let’s be honest—the truth is sometimes hard. A rapist is not a nonconsensual sex partner. A drug dealer is not an undocumented pharmacist. No one is worried about hurting their feelings clearly.

I understand that America is truly the land of promise for many. I sympathize with many citizens, especially those in Mexico oppressed under a corrupt government and stuck in a cycle of poverty. But in our compassion, let us not condone breaking the law and teach that laws are only to be followed when things are easy. This petition skews the issue. Rather than a simple term, we should be focusing on how we can aid oppressed people and streamline the immigration process to make it feasible for foreigners, especially Mexican citizens to live in America.

I am not anti-immigrant. My family immigrated from Germany in the 60s and we did it legally. There is no reason why other people should not be called out for skipping the process and breaking the line when people like my family follow America's policy.

Steinar Andersen
Steinar Andersen
  • Alexandra Seelig

This legal immigrant agrees with you.

Lewis Bloomfield
Lewis Bloomfield
  • Alexandra Seelig

ok then Ross, how about criminal. Lets just call them criminals, all those criminals, because that sounds better right!??

Jesus this thing is full of all sorts of stupid.

William Brummett
William Brummett
  • Alexandra Seelig

Ross Warsing and they do it everyday so they are illegal

Mike Nolan
Mike Nolan
  • Alexandra Seelig

Actually, no criminal laws have been broken by individuals who entered the country without documents. Your statement shows bitterness rather than facts.

David Polk
David Polk
  • Alexandra Seelig

I agree lets call them by the name that they are lawbreaking, tax money stealing, immigrants that come here illegally by breaking the law set forth in our land

Sharyn Beers
Sharyn Beers
  • Alexandra Seelig

Actually, the correct legal term is "illegal alien". The word "immigrant" means one who intends to settle in a place, which illegal aliens could not do because their presence here is illegal, meaning against the law. The word "alien" means only that they are not US citizens. Therefore, any term other than "illegal alien" is legally incorrect.

Ñañel Matar
Ñañel Matar

I like the term "undocumented citizen" better, but anyways, I really don't give a monkey's butt of what crap people say.

Keith Eric Iholts II
Keith Eric Iholts II

Ok, Ill stop using the word illegal alien and go straight to the point. Criminal or invader. If you are hear without due process than you are a criminal or a foreign invader. Quit trying to be political correct and start helping Americans as this is even more unfair to those who migrated to this country legally. Its sad and pathetic we live in a nation that helps criminals more than its own citizens and looks to helping those who hate and despise our nation and laugh and the soft pathetic...

Ok, Ill stop using the word illegal alien and go straight to the point. Criminal or invader. If you are hear without due process than you are a criminal or a foreign invader. Quit trying to be political correct and start helping Americans as this is even more unfair to those who migrated to this country legally. Its sad and pathetic we live in a nation that helps criminals more than its own citizens and looks to helping those who hate and despise our nation and laugh and the soft pathetic under-bellied fools who think themselves altruists. Its a pathetic attempt at inflating ones hubris and arrogance.

Beemeth Robles
Beemeth Robles

The AP is the epitome of liberal media so it should not surprise anyone that they go along with the PC crowd. The problem with media like AP is that they do not want to deal with facts, they simply want to provide nonsense in order to redefine the facts. I hope the New York Times has more guts and commonsense.

Johann Vossie Vorster
Johann Vossie Vorster

if a person is a illegal immigrant what else is this person. we sit with thousands in south africa.

Harriet Hammons
Harriet Hammons

We need to say undocumented people
Lets get this immigration issue resolved UMWomen are reading Immigration in the Bible immigration goes back to the beginning of time
God bless the USA and the World Harriet Haamons

Robi Schwab
Robi Schwab

I want to know something before I sign this petition okay. If calling an "illegal immigrant" what they are, illegal immigrants, is wrong, then what should they be called? Has anybody ever stopped and thought of this?

CaptBhushan Datta
CaptBhushan Datta

I Agree

Sandy Lyons
Sandy Lyons

Sorry, if an individual does not follow the law of the country he is in, then he is doing something illegal. Calling the action by another name or word does not make that action legal.

See more comments…