Greg Hahn
Greg Hahn

I wonder if she, or her parents, could buy the cookies and then do the donation website. Would this fall under the first sale doctrine?

Kimberly Reynolds
Kimberly Reynolds
  • Greg Hahn

Emma started her own website at treats2troops.org but she is sending Oreos and coffee instead :)

Teresa Donaldson Peal
Teresa Donaldson Peal
  • Greg Hahn

I have supported troops for quiet awhile & believe me they love getting cookies from home they say it makes them feel closer to home , & the coffee is a nice touch , they love Star Bucks . Kudos to your daughter for her actions , she sounds like an awesome person . I hesitate to say little girl , because she sounds so grown up , you have done a remarkable job with your daughter . I admire her for her actions , & you for helping her fight for her cause , you two make a good team . Good luck...

I have supported troops for quiet awhile & believe me they love getting cookies from home they say it makes them feel closer to home , & the coffee is a nice touch , they love Star Bucks . Kudos to your daughter for her actions , she sounds like an awesome person . I hesitate to say little girl , because she sounds so grown up , you have done a remarkable job with your daughter . I admire her for her actions , & you for helping her fight for her cause , you two make a good team . Good luck on your adventure I hope you nail them to the wall .I can't imagine why they want to throw perfectly good cookies away , it makes no sense to me as to the rest of the one that have replied to your post .Again good luck fighting the power that be ~~~ the ones that thinks they are always right & the ones that don't want to get involved , as you said the Head office told you they had no control over each troop ~~ that is a load of bunk ~~~~ they are the heart of the whole Origination , if the Head Origination heard about something they were doing , that was against their rules , don't think for a moment they wouldn't wade in on the situation . They just don't want to get their hands dirty on this one . They want to leave it on the troops door steeps in the town that you live in .

Ceil Kessler
Ceil Kessler

The Girl Scouts are allowed to return 1% of all sales to ABC Bakery for a full refund. (It actually explains this in the news article, if anyone read it.) If the bakery is offering this return as part of business, then the bakery is the one that should be donating these cookies. Your petition should be for ABC Bakery, not for the Girl Scouts. Though I'm sure all of this ridiculousness is taking up enough of the Girl Scouts' resources that they'll be pressuring ABC Bakery themselves now. I...

The Girl Scouts are allowed to return 1% of all sales to ABC Bakery for a full refund. (It actually explains this in the news article, if anyone read it.) If the bakery is offering this return as part of business, then the bakery is the one that should be donating these cookies. Your petition should be for ABC Bakery, not for the Girl Scouts. Though I'm sure all of this ridiculousness is taking up enough of the Girl Scouts' resources that they'll be pressuring ABC Bakery themselves now. I love how people stir the pot and put pressure on the wrong people before they know what's going on.

Ceil Kessler
Ceil Kessler
  • Ceil Kessler

It's ok, I haven't sent the cookies yet!

Kimberly Reynolds
Kimberly Reynolds
  • Ceil Kessler

Actually, the bakery give the Girl Scouts credit for the cookies. It is up to the Girl Scouts to do what they will with the cookies. Therefore, Girl Scouts need to have a policy as to this type of situation. If it were up to ABC, then the Girl Scouts, as their customer, could have them donate the cookies. Either way, the buck needs to stop with the organization who has their name on the box. Business 101.

Ceil Kessler
Ceil Kessler
  • Ceil Kessler

My guess is that they had no idea what the bakery was doing with the 1% they got credit for. For all they knew, they were giving them to employees. I don't have a problem with the petition, but I do take issue with the tone. People are acting like they're kicking dogs, and laughing about it. I think all you'd have to do is ask them to donate them. My experience with the Girl Scouts is that they're reasonable people.

Kimberly Reynolds
Kimberly Reynolds
  • Ceil Kessler

The bakery didn't even have the cookies. They were in the Girl Scouts warehouse. I agree, this is not infanticide, but if you knew the horrible way they treated Emma, you would not find them to be reasonable at all. Though, again, I recognize that this is just one council, not the whole organization. However, there has been a distinct lack of attention or responsibility in this matter by the organization as a whole. At some point, some one needs to advocate change. In this case, it is an 11 year old.

Renee DiCesare
Renee DiCesare

OMGoodnes, what a waste! We saw the video on the news, and i got mad, because they're trashing perfectly good cookies that can be sent to our troops, and given to the homeless and food pantries. Donate any cookies that are left!

Evelyn Painter
Evelyn Painter
  • Renee DiCesare

I HAVE SAID THIS FOR YEARS AND BEEN TOLD NO... SOME OF OUR CUSTOMERS / PEOPLE BUY TO SEND TO TROOPS.. I WORK WITH A GROUP ...BEAMS OF LIGHT... WHO SENDS CARE PKGS. EACH MONTH TO AT LEAST 20 TO 30 SOLDIERS... JUST POSTAGE IS SO COSTLY..NO WE DO NOT SEND FOR FREE..GOVERNMENT SAID THEY HAVE NO FUNDING FOR SUCH THINGS... NOW I FIND THEY ARE TRASHING THE VERY THINGS WE SPEND OUR MONEY ON ...MAKES ME FURIOUS.. I CANNOT STOP THINKING OF JUST WHAT A WASTE THIS IS.. SO MUCH GOOD COULD COME FROM...

I HAVE SAID THIS FOR YEARS AND BEEN TOLD NO... SOME OF OUR CUSTOMERS / PEOPLE BUY TO SEND TO TROOPS.. I WORK WITH A GROUP ...BEAMS OF LIGHT... WHO SENDS CARE PKGS. EACH MONTH TO AT LEAST 20 TO 30 SOLDIERS... JUST POSTAGE IS SO COSTLY..NO WE DO NOT SEND FOR FREE..GOVERNMENT SAID THEY HAVE NO FUNDING FOR SUCH THINGS... NOW I FIND THEY ARE TRASHING THE VERY THINGS WE SPEND OUR MONEY ON ...MAKES ME FURIOUS.. I CANNOT STOP THINKING OF JUST WHAT A WASTE THIS IS.. SO MUCH GOOD COULD COME FROM WHAT THEY ARE TRASHING.. MY SCOUT CO- LEADER BROUGHT THIS TO MY ATTENTION THIS MORNING AND I AM STILL KEYED UP..

I AM 65 YRS. AND STILL GET UPSET AT SUCH THINGS...I AM A SR. ON FIXED INCOME AND I KNOW I HAVE TO BUY MY COOKIES TO SEND OVER TO SOLDIERS WHO LOVE THEM..AND WAIT FOR THEM IN SPRING.. MAY GOD FORBID THAT WE TRASH THEM AGAIN........THEY ARE A BIT OF HOME TO THOSE OVER THERE WHO ARE IN HARMS WAY..FIGHTING FOR US...PLEASE, SOMEONE MAKE SURE THIS YEAR THEY GO TO SOME GOOD USES AND NOT A TRASH DUMP...:( :(

Marlene LaCombe
Marlene LaCombe
  • Renee DiCesare

AMEN EVELYN!

Kevlin Charles
Kevlin Charles
  • Renee DiCesare

It is better to toss the cookies in the trash......The Troops don't need all this sugar poison..
Send them something of real value other than junk sugar cookies......

Paul Cofrancesco
Paul Cofrancesco
  • Renee DiCesare

Thanks for speaking up - you obviously grew up in a generation that cared - waste not, want not. Emma needs the support and wisdom of elders like you.

Robert Viehweger
Robert Viehweger
  • Renee DiCesare

I want to see you thousands of miles from home with nothing but sand and death waiting around any and every corner, Charles. Then I want someone to consider sending you something to remind you of home, then saying, "Nah, this is the bad part of home.. cookies are evil and they don't need this." You, sir, are a dick.

David Smith
David Smith
  • Renee DiCesare

Charles Dickens

@Charles Kevlin--I really don't know how to properly respond to this "Holier than thou" attitude, other than - I am really glad that Philadelphia is not in America. If it were, I would not be surprised at anything that happened.

Krysta Swartz
Krysta Swartz
  • Renee DiCesare

Charles quit being an idiot, apparently you have never been in the military

Judi Magruder
Judi Magruder
  • Renee DiCesare

YOU'RE AN IDIOT CHARLES KEVLIN....TROOPS DO NEED SUGAR, JUST CAUSE YOU ARE OLD AND FAT AND SHOULDN'T HAVE SUGAR...OUR TROOPS ARE IN GREAT SHAPE AND A FEW COOKIES WON'T HURT THEM!!!!! SO PLEASE TAKE YOUR VERY UNSMART REMARK OUT OF HERE!!!!

Dan Whisler
Dan Whisler
  • Renee DiCesare

Charles Kevlin, have you ever spent time in war? sugar is NOT a problem, it's a comfort!
but that's not the issue here, now go eat your brussel sprouts!!!

Robert Hendrix
Robert Hendrix
  • Renee DiCesare

ok so send them some where else u dont throw food away when there r starving people in it m u no 1 dollar a day will help all theese kids all over the world send cookies

Kelly Vollmer
Kelly Vollmer

This girl is exhibiting all the values she is supposed to learn as a Girl Scout, but they want to kick her out? There is something very wrong with that!

Amanda Dike
Amanda Dike
  • Kelly Vollmer

I hate to say it, but this reminds me of what the boyscouts are doing to. I thought that these organizations were about morals and values. I think this is a joke, my kids will not join any troop what so ever. I will teach my kids morals and values on my own. I realize that I am just one person, but I'm going to try my best. Kudo's to Emma for trying to do something that's right

Kimberly Reynolds
Kimberly Reynolds
  • Kelly Vollmer

I agree Kelly. Emma worked 12 hours this weekend at booths, selling cookies. After hearing about this petition, I suddenly get a call from Girl Scouts saying Emma is being removed from her troop. It is wrong.

Kate Glenn
Kate Glenn
  • Kelly Vollmer

I'm sure the GS are not prepared to handle the situation or the publicity...or they wouldn't be tossing cookies! This is a story to support the organization getting their crumbs together and the GS being reinstated....<3

Diann Thome
Diann Thome
  • Kelly Vollmer

NO she should NOT be removed from her troop! THat is just plain outright WRONG.

Diann Thome
Diann Thome
  • Kelly Vollmer

I don't think GS cookies are food (read the ingredient list...) but I WILL sign the petition now, because that's simply just an evil way to treat this child. She is smart, she has ideas, she needs to be heard. And the troops to whom these cookies could be sent can decide yes or no on consuming them.

Barbara Louise
Barbara Louise
  • Kelly Vollmer

I agree!

Barbara Louise
Barbara Louise
  • Kelly Vollmer

Kimberly Reynolds: I suggest forming national organization to fight for her rights as an American and as a Girl Scout. Sue the scum. They make me very angry. Once a Girl Scout, always a Girl Scout. They have shamed me as a Girl Scout.

Let me know. Form it, and I will join.

Evelyn Painter
Evelyn Painter
  • Kelly Vollmer

Kimberly Reynolds SO SO WRONG...

Beth Turner
Beth Turner
  • Kelly Vollmer

Kate Glenn was it your local council who called you, or GS of USA?

Kenny Williams
Kenny Williams

Way to go Emma! I'm encouraging everyone to sign and share with others..please :-)

Chris McCabe
Chris McCabe
  • Kenny Williams

Waste is evil!

Kenny Williams
Kenny Williams
  • Kenny Williams

Good morning Chris. Sadly a lot of humans are evil.

Harold Ivie
Harold Ivie

I think it's a very good idea, an idea I can easily support, so I came here to sign the petition assuming it was a way to express my approval of a good idea: But I could not sign a petition that 'Demands' anyone give away and pay to ship what belongs to them. Where do those who 'Demand' get the crust? I didn't sign the petition because it is outrageous.

Harold Ivie
Harold Ivie
  • Harold Ivie

Think I'd like to add: How bout those who 'Demand' the cookies be sent pony up the 'costs'...hmmm??

Kimberly Reynolds
Kimberly Reynolds
  • Harold Ivie

Harold Ivie Actually, Operation Gratitude will ship them at no cost. It doesn't cost the Girl Scouts anything either. Though if makes you feel better, Emma is more than happy to toss in her allowance...well, should would but she already donated her allowance to the Red Cross.

Sarah E Foster
Sarah E Foster

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE DONATE THEM TO LOCAL FOODBANKS> THERE ARE FELLOW GIRL SCOUTS ON THE BASES OVERSEAS TRYING TO SELL COOKIES AS THEIR FUNDRAISERS!

Sarah E Foster
Sarah E Foster
  • Sarah E Foster

Also of interest: she's being investigated for selling cookies ONLINE which is illegal. Notice she's says for pointing out the cookies being trashed...

Kimberly Reynolds
Kimberly Reynolds
  • Sarah E Foster

Sarah you should get you facts straight before you try to slander an 11 year old. She was not selling online, she was collecting donations for the Girl Scouts I Care program. There is no investigation. They approved of her social media effort originally, then they changed their mind when her troop leader complained. they asked her to stop collecting donations online and she did.

James A Koplin III
James A Koplin III

It isn't the Girl Scouts that did this. It is the bakery that did it. They should be going after the bakery not the Girl Scouts....I agree there it too much waste, but it isn't the Girl Scout

James A Koplin III
James A Koplin III
  • James A Koplin III

They do not own the bakery.

Kimberly Reynolds
Kimberly Reynolds
  • James A Koplin III

They do not own the bakery but they were in possession of the cookies. Girl Scouts threw them away, not the bakery.

Melissa Grim
Melissa Grim

When I tried to join the Girl Scouts, they said they would call back by January and if we didn't get a call to call them. They never called and when we called them, they were very rude, so we decided not to join.

Kimmi Cook
Kimmi Cook
  • Melissa Grim

Start one of these clubs instead! http://www.kidscare.org/about

Melissa Grim
Melissa Grim
  • Melissa Grim

Thanks for the great idea!

Diann Thome
Diann Thome

She cannot contact people she knows in the troop? What if they've been long tern her best friends? Okay, This truly TRULY TRULY irritates.

I am going to tell everyone I know never to buy another GS cookie until the organization apologizes up front. Big time and splashy ads. I don't buy them myself, but I have helped support friends who do.

Diann Thome
Diann Thome
  • Diann Thome

My own comment: GS cookies make my tummy rumble in a bad way. And, I do not consider them food, if you read the ingredient list. However here we have a 11 year old girl finding a solution for unsold cookies that means they won't go to waste and perhaps those troops overseas can make their own choices and eat as they choose -- and there will be less waste. The GS are trying to kick her out unless she conforms to their "ideals" whatever those are. Frankly, I wasn't going to sign the initial...

My own comment: GS cookies make my tummy rumble in a bad way. And, I do not consider them food, if you read the ingredient list. However here we have a 11 year old girl finding a solution for unsold cookies that means they won't go to waste and perhaps those troops overseas can make their own choices and eat as they choose -- and there will be less waste. The GS are trying to kick her out unless she conforms to their "ideals" whatever those are. Frankly, I wasn't going to sign the initial petition, since I'd prefer real food being put together, but this thing from the GS seems to go after her simply since she spoke out. Read the site and make your own decisions.

Robert Hendrix
Robert Hendrix
  • Diann Thome

i agree they went after a 11 year old girl shame on the GS for going after the little girl

See more comments…