Bronwyn Shivers
Bronwyn Shivers

NO, THEY ARE A GIFT FROM GOD, NOT AN ITEM YOU PICK UP AT A LOCAL STORE, YOU HAVE TO LIVE WITH YOUR OWN SELF IF YOU SELL THEM. NOW DONATING, THAT's DIFFERENT, I GIVE BLOOD AND WOULD NOT TAKE A PENNY FOR IT, NOW HERE IS THE FLIP SIDE, IF YOU HAVE A FAMILY MEMBER WHO DONATES THEIR ORGANS THAT's FINE, DONATE, KEY WORD, JUST LOOK AT WHAT HAS HAPPENED IN THE WORLD TODDAY WITH SOME MANY WRONG DECISIONS, TODAY, FOR ME PRAYER IN SCHOOL REMOVED, PRAYER BEFORE MEALS, WHERE DO WE DRAW THE LINE? WHO IS...

NO, THEY ARE A GIFT FROM GOD, NOT AN ITEM YOU PICK UP AT A LOCAL STORE, YOU HAVE TO LIVE WITH YOUR OWN SELF IF YOU SELL THEM. NOW DONATING, THAT's DIFFERENT, I GIVE BLOOD AND WOULD NOT TAKE A PENNY FOR IT, NOW HERE IS THE FLIP SIDE, IF YOU HAVE A FAMILY MEMBER WHO DONATES THEIR ORGANS THAT's FINE, DONATE, KEY WORD, JUST LOOK AT WHAT HAS HAPPENED IN THE WORLD TODDAY WITH SOME MANY WRONG DECISIONS, TODAY, FOR ME PRAYER IN SCHOOL REMOVED, PRAYER BEFORE MEALS, WHERE DO WE DRAW THE LINE? WHO IS TO JUDGE, I JUST PRAY AND ASK GOD FOR THE ANSWER AND GUIDANCE, MY OPINION ONLY!

Carla M Lynch-Pledger
Carla M Lynch-Pledger
  • Bronwyn Shivers

I truly feel the same way as you. Thanks for your comment.

Erich Scheffl
Erich Scheffl

Don't put money in. Then always Moral disappeares. We changed our environment, caused by the greed for money, have new deseases (more cancer by x-rays, etc.), and create now a market. It's o.k. when you have an accident and donate your organs, or if you want to help one. But don't sell them. You will see that criminals will occur when they can earn money. For me it is not moralic, when money is involved. This can only be American thinking. Because you are already conditioned on money. And...

Don't put money in. Then always Moral disappeares. We changed our environment, caused by the greed for money, have new deseases (more cancer by x-rays, etc.), and create now a market. It's o.k. when you have an accident and donate your organs, or if you want to help one. But don't sell them. You will see that criminals will occur when they can earn money. For me it is not moralic, when money is involved. This can only be American thinking. Because you are already conditioned on money. And you are not aware. Not everything can be buyable. Unfortunately some of you are already sold.

Amanda C. Rodriguez
Amanda C. Rodriguez
  • Erich Scheffl

Obviously, you know nothing about Americans. You shouldn't talk bad about a type of people that you don't even know. That's worse than racism! You got something against Americans......or Money?
Whoever taught you these morals and views on how life really is, isn't very intelligent. In fact, I would call them stupid when it comes to the English language because you can't spell and your grammar is incorrect. I don't feel you have any concept of America. Who are you to say anything negative about Americans? You should be ashamed of yourself!

Ashok Sehgal
Ashok Sehgal

Yes! you may! but with one condition!
First try and replace the word DONOR with SELLER.

Gloria Tellier
Gloria Tellier

Financial gain or not is not a black/white issue. If my ultimate goal in donating a organ or part of an organ (liver) is to help someone, and that person offers financial reward, why should taking financial reward illegal?

Paula Pederson
Paula Pederson

I don't see it as a monetary payment if it comes in the form of medical card credit. I don't know anyone personally waiting for an organ. You can help people waiting and those getting credit could be someone who cant afford health care for some unrelated problem. There is already a black market for organs. Using the
medical card solution I don't believe will enhance the black market but could enhance life for those waiting and those giving.

Abolnour Ashraf
Abolnour Ashraf

I said No,it might lead to a black market,there is no legal black market,all are illegal

Mike Richardson
Mike Richardson

It's a choice of personel preference I believe it depends on circumstances and who is receiving the organ.

Rita O'Meara
Rita O'Meara

No because this is a gift of love ...no amount of money could replace this love.

Betty K Pace
Betty K Pace

Leave it as it is; when you die and donate what is still good for someone in need is the way to go....since you won't need the organs any more......it is just wrong to "sell" off what God gave you for MONEY!

Barbara Billings Sloan
Barbara Billings Sloan

Each case of organ donation should be dealt with on an indivdual basis. Some people experience financial hardships, so are driven more by money than a gift from the heart. We should not judge...we should be thankful for the availability to help those in need. Let's face it, you are never going to stop the practice of peoplewho donate blood for money to buy booze, cigarettes and things we don't feel are necessary. The option of free medical care should alsoe put on the table in lieu of monetary settlement and the donr shoud be allowed to decide.

See more comments…