Like Causes?

Install the App
TRY NOW

house Bill H.R. 6201

Providing Free Coronavirus Testing, Paid Leave, Plus Expanded Food Aid & Unemployment Benefits During the Outbreak

Argument in favor

It may not be perfect, but the updated version of this bill represents a genuine, bipartisan compromise between Democrats & Republicans to protect Americans from the harmful effects of the coronavirus outbreak by ensuring they can get tested at no cost, have access to paid leave, food security programs, and unemployment insurance if they get sick.

Dicr's Opinion
···
03/12/2020
Let’s be realistic, Moscow Mitch doesn’t lift a finger unless he gets all the credit for something. Along with Rand Paul, Kentucky Senator’s have been screwing over America for years with their selfish voting.
Like (361)
Follow
Share
Yours.Truly's Opinion
···
03/12/2020
Providing free testing and care, plus food aid and other things that will actually help working people in this pandemic, is a much better thing to do than lowering the payroll tax or bailing out shale companies.
Like (289)
Follow
Share
jimK's Opinion
···
03/12/2020
UPDATED: Another reason that broad scale testing is needed is to identify those who have already unknowingly contracted COVID-19 and recovered. If these people are health workers, they can operate more effectively without the added fear of contracting the disease. If they are seniors, they will know that they can safely help watch the kids that being kept home from school and free-up healthcare workers or those economically distressed parents unable to work from home. It is part of aiding the recovery to know who has contracted this disease and has recovered- these folks can be invaluable resources in helping the country cope during this health emergency. … … … trump’s plan boils down to using a pandemic as an excuse to further goose the economy and has fairly little to do with protecting the populace. The economy has been propped up already so far that we can look forward to an extreme recession if not a full blown depression - and all his unprecedented propping up has sacrificed much of the margins needed for realistic economic stimulus needed to recover. trump’s actions so far have been mainly for economic electability. The pandemic is a big deal; the only country that appears to have it’s spread under control is China and the only reason it is under control is China, due to the massive control of their populace by means that most democracies could not exert over their population. There can be no effective control if you cannot measure the extent of the problem, that is why testing must be available to everyone that needs it- wether they have insurance or not. Covering sick time income losses is mandatory because we need to keep all infected people from spreading the disease. It has nothing to do with being a ‘welfare state’; it has everything to do with protecting our country from a preventable disaster. It is not unlike calling the Army Corp of Engineers to protect coastal cities by building barriers for storm surge or managing water runoff in areas prone to flooding. It is much like anticipating a known disaster and investing to mitigate it’s impact. If trumpublicans block this sound apolitical legislation in order to politicize it, they will be adding to our country’s irresponsible delays and will further damage our future. Our Country’s response has been an international embarrassment. This is a spreading humanitarian disaster supported by facts and world-wide measures that we cannot seem to muster. Disinformation campaigns can’t fix the problem- only concrete expedient actions will. Increasing ‘capital liquidity’ and reducing payroll taxes are not the answers; The ‘all-significant’ markets indices further collapse today proves that even big money does not support trump’s asinine solutions and highlights our government’s demonstrated lack of leadership.
Like (272)
Follow
Share

Argument opposed

The updated version of this bill is only a marginal improvement on the original, and still constitutes a drastic overreach of the federal government. It is still a massive extension of federal welfare programs, and the House is going to vote on it before a cost estimate is available to gauge how it will spend taxpayer dollars to grow the deficit.

B.R.'s Opinion
···
03/12/2020
I would not approve this bill as written. While there are some valid recommendations, there are others that are unrelated to the issues of the virus and appear to be past wish list items woven in.
Like (62)
Follow
Share
Ronald's Opinion
···
03/12/2020
Food aid, and unemployment are Democrat wish list items. Just say "NO". Payroll tax holiday for employers, and employees will deal better with this situation. Above all: All Politicians Must warn against panic. This morning in my local supermarket I saw panic buying I have not seen since the 2K Farce. Media, and Democrats, and drive by media must denounce this. It will lead to violence, shortages, and issues not needed. If Democrats, deep state traitors, or media cared about any American Citizen they would be warning against panic, hoarding food, or money. Anything else in this situation. People working to make life harder in a crisis are not your friends. They are to be opposed. Federal Government isw not the answer to this, or any crisis. Our Free Market has helped far more people than any government, ever.
Like (33)
Follow
Share
David's Opinion
···
03/12/2020
You Democrats don’t waste any time in expanding the welfare state in order to buy more votes. Having said that, I think the measure is premature. I’m open to consider each issue *individually* later on.
Like (8)
Follow
Share
    Let’s be realistic, Moscow Mitch doesn’t lift a finger unless he gets all the credit for something. Along with Rand Paul, Kentucky Senator’s have been screwing over America for years with their selfish voting.
    Like (361)
    Follow
    Share
    I would not approve this bill as written. While there are some valid recommendations, there are others that are unrelated to the issues of the virus and appear to be past wish list items woven in.
    Like (62)
    Follow
    Share
    Providing free testing and care, plus food aid and other things that will actually help working people in this pandemic, is a much better thing to do than lowering the payroll tax or bailing out shale companies.
    Like (289)
    Follow
    Share
    UPDATED: Another reason that broad scale testing is needed is to identify those who have already unknowingly contracted COVID-19 and recovered. If these people are health workers, they can operate more effectively without the added fear of contracting the disease. If they are seniors, they will know that they can safely help watch the kids that being kept home from school and free-up healthcare workers or those economically distressed parents unable to work from home. It is part of aiding the recovery to know who has contracted this disease and has recovered- these folks can be invaluable resources in helping the country cope during this health emergency. … … … trump’s plan boils down to using a pandemic as an excuse to further goose the economy and has fairly little to do with protecting the populace. The economy has been propped up already so far that we can look forward to an extreme recession if not a full blown depression - and all his unprecedented propping up has sacrificed much of the margins needed for realistic economic stimulus needed to recover. trump’s actions so far have been mainly for economic electability. The pandemic is a big deal; the only country that appears to have it’s spread under control is China and the only reason it is under control is China, due to the massive control of their populace by means that most democracies could not exert over their population. There can be no effective control if you cannot measure the extent of the problem, that is why testing must be available to everyone that needs it- wether they have insurance or not. Covering sick time income losses is mandatory because we need to keep all infected people from spreading the disease. It has nothing to do with being a ‘welfare state’; it has everything to do with protecting our country from a preventable disaster. It is not unlike calling the Army Corp of Engineers to protect coastal cities by building barriers for storm surge or managing water runoff in areas prone to flooding. It is much like anticipating a known disaster and investing to mitigate it’s impact. If trumpublicans block this sound apolitical legislation in order to politicize it, they will be adding to our country’s irresponsible delays and will further damage our future. Our Country’s response has been an international embarrassment. This is a spreading humanitarian disaster supported by facts and world-wide measures that we cannot seem to muster. Disinformation campaigns can’t fix the problem- only concrete expedient actions will. Increasing ‘capital liquidity’ and reducing payroll taxes are not the answers; The ‘all-significant’ markets indices further collapse today proves that even big money does not support trump’s asinine solutions and highlights our government’s demonstrated lack of leadership.
    Like (272)
    Follow
    Share
    Strong measures so people can stay home while sick, or care for kids during school shutdowns will not only lessen spread but restore confidence of citizens & the stock market! Luckily, governors handle day-to-day operations conducting daily televised briefings while Mitch McConnell contemplated Senate recess for 10 days but instead opted for a 3 day long weekend. Fund the states & let them get the job done using their evidence-based public health experts! @Robert: Agree this should not be political. Suggest Countable posters stop with the politics and address the pros & cons of options. Tired of hearing people or parties called dumb or stupid! Thank you Jamie Raskin for voting “Yea”! List of 40 House Representatives voting “Nay”! [NOTE: All Republicans] Bradley Byrne Ala. 1 Andy Biggs Ariz. 5 Debbie Lesko Ariz. 8 Tom McClintock Calif. 4 Ken Buck Colo. 4 Michael Waltz Fla. 6 Greg Steube Fla. 17 Jody B. Hice Ga. 10 Barry Loudermilk Ga. 11 Steve King Iowa 4 Russ Fulcher Idaho 1 Jim Banks Ind. 3 Tom Emmer Minn. 6 Billy Long Mo. 7 Jason Smith Mo. 8 Dan Bishop N.C. 9 Ted Budd N.C. 13 Jim Jordan Ohio 4 Warren Davidson Ohio 8 Kevin Hern Okla. 1 Joe Wilson S.C. 2 Jeff Duncan S.C. 3 William R. Timmons IV S.C. 4 Ralph Norman S.C. 5 Tim Burchett Tenn. 2 Scott DesJarlais Tenn. 4 John W. Rose Tenn. 6 Mark E. Green Tenn. 7 Louie Gohmert Tex. 1 Lance Gooden Tex. 5 Randy Weber Tex. 14 Chip Roy Tex. 21 Michael Cloud Tex. 27 Brian Babin Tex. 36 Ben Cline Va. 6 Bryan Steil Wis. 1 Jim Sensenbrenner Wis. 5 Glenn Grothman Wis. 6 Mike Gallagher Wis. 8 Alex X. Mooney W.Va. 2 https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/14/us/politics/coronavirus-house-vote.html
    Like (117)
    Follow
    Share
    This legislation is at least a month late. The GOP hitched its wagon to Donald Trump thinking it will take them to the mountain top. How long will they stay hitched before they realize it's leading them off a cliff?
    Like (95)
    Follow
    Share
    If Korea could test 10,000 a day since January, why is it that we haven’t even tested that much altogether?? Ofc w/out tests, could it be that Trumps “numbers” wouldn’t look so good if they rose?
    Like (63)
    Follow
    Share
    The focus is on health, security, and well-being of people, unlike Trump's preoccupation on banks, businesses, and the stock market.
    Like (58)
    Follow
    Share
    Yes, but the horse is already out of the barn. Free of charge testing sounds good until you realize that there are no test available. Too little too late.
    Like (49)
    Follow
    Share
    Katie Porter is the BOMB! (congress woman from CA) If you don't know about her, find the interview from Lawrence O'Donnell on 3/12. Katie held the head of the CDC to the fire today. He is legally authorized to release funds in a health emergency. OMG! she got him to say, "Yes." The release of funds do not require any legislation. I believe it's 20 billion. Covid-19 testing is going to be FREE to EVERY AMERICAN! He said YES that he would use his lawful authority! I would love to be a fly on the wall during the discussion with the orange one.
    Like (46)
    Follow
    Share
    Only way to stop this epidemic is by supporting public health, providing free testing and healthcare and paying people to stay home if exposed or ill.
    Like (44)
    Follow
    Share
    @Pedro and @Dave since you said the exact same thing bots. I’m curious. How much later on are you willing to consider this bill? The Market has tanked twice in one week making another first for the Trump Administration. With the Market at 21,580 I quit watching. We are in a Bear market after 11 years of Bull. WHO has declared a Global Pandemic and the WH is not only not prepared but deliberately concealing and floating misinformation about COVID-19 to the Public. Will you wait until everyone has been exposed? Until it has so effected the economy that we can’t recover for decades as in the Depression? Until the death toll reaches a certain point? What is your it’s not premature point?
    Like (35)
    Follow
    Share
    A friend in NY who has insurance was exposed to the coronavirus and it was recommended that he be tested because he had mild symptoms. The test after insurance was $600. If he had no insurance it would cost $1000. This is a public health matter. If we are to flatten the curve of the spread of the virus, as Dr. Fauci is urging us to attempt to do, testing has to be widespread and be either no cost or negligible cost. No one should profit from this outbreak. Testing needs to be widespread and easily gotten. Not doing what’s necessary to float us all through this unchartered territory will cost us all even more dearly. The incompetence of this administration’s handling of this crisis and Trump’s minimizing and politicizing the crisis has delayed our response. He’s the wrong man to speak to the public. Between Fox News and Trump a sizable proportion of people still think the virus is a hoax cooked up by Democrats. This is dystopian theater. It has to stop.
    Like (34)
    Follow
    Share
    Food aid, and unemployment are Democrat wish list items. Just say "NO". Payroll tax holiday for employers, and employees will deal better with this situation. Above all: All Politicians Must warn against panic. This morning in my local supermarket I saw panic buying I have not seen since the 2K Farce. Media, and Democrats, and drive by media must denounce this. It will lead to violence, shortages, and issues not needed. If Democrats, deep state traitors, or media cared about any American Citizen they would be warning against panic, hoarding food, or money. Anything else in this situation. People working to make life harder in a crisis are not your friends. They are to be opposed. Federal Government isw not the answer to this, or any crisis. Our Free Market has helped far more people than any government, ever.
    Like (33)
    Follow
    Share
    As I write this all major sports are shutting down. Broadway, Disney. DC. Children in this country rely on school. For food, safety AND EDUCATION. This is disgusting. A Disgrace. As I write this the tRumpublicans are still in Court fighting the ACA. Fighting against coverage of pre-existing conditions. The most vulnerable among us. The tRumplicans are fighting IN REAL TIME RIGHT NOW AGAINST FREE TESTS, FOOD AND VACCINES. AS I WRITE THIS. POTUS is lying . Over and over again. I find some of this to be very rich and interesting. Wonderful obnoxious Matt Gaetz wearing a gas mask in the Capital just to be obnoxious. Now in quarantine. Rick Scott acting like a responsible leader, standing by THE MAN. Now in question. AS I write this can’t help but to review tRump economy plan for this year. This proposal cut. $750,0000 from CDC. As I write this AMERICANS ARE DYING. You tRumpsters are pathetic and dangerous. I hope we are ALL WRONG. I WISH YOU HEALTH. I HOPE YOU DON’T HAVE SENIORS THAT YOU LOVE. AS I WRITE THIS I AM SCARED FOR OUR COUNTRY. I WANT F*#&#Ing TESTS
    Like (27)
    Follow
    Share
    This should not be a political situation like quite a few in both sides have made it. We need solutions, this is what you were elected to do, work together and lead the country. Stop the political infighting!
    Like (27)
    Follow
    Share
    In what world shouldn’t testing be free of charge when a national emergency is in place? That just SCREAMS eliminate the lower class. Just saying.
    Like (24)
    Follow
    Share
    This plan is much more of a working plan than the “plan” Trump rolled out. A tax break isn’t going to help a lot of people especially those on SNAP who need it to feed their children, particularly since the mean, nasty Republicans are still planning on cutting SNAP EVEN AS WE ARE FACING THE LOSS OF MUCH OF THE LOWER INCOME EARNERS INCOME. HOW IS CUTTING PAYROLL TAX FOR PEOPLE GOING TO HELP ANYTHING??? What if they lose their job??? What if their hours are cut?? There is not going to be any money for the families!!!! HIW IS THE GOVERNMENT GOING TO PAY FOR TRUMP’S GOLFING TRIPS IF OUR PAYROLL TAXES ARE CUT. WE ARE THE ONLY ONES PAYING INTO THE GOVERNMENT BECAUSE OF THE REPUBLICANS CUTTING ALL TAXES PAID BY THOSE WITH THE MONEY TO PAY —-THE RICH!!!!
    Like (23)
    Follow
    Share
    We are so far behind. Pence is NOT a leader and not right for this job. Get real scientists NOW.
    Like (22)
    Follow
    Share
    We need everyone who may think he has Covid-19 to feel able to go to their doctor and get tested. This bill removes barriers that might stop people doing that and you MUST VOTE YES!!
    Like (20)
    Follow
    Share
    MORE