Like Causes?

Install the App
TRY NOW

house Bill H.R. 2526

Should Graduate and Professional Students be Eligible for Federally Subsidized Student Loans?

Argument in favor

Reinstating the eligibility of graduate and professional students for federally subsidized student loans would help more people develop their skills and contribute to the American economy.

Staci's Opinion
···
08/20/2017
I am currently a grad student getting my masters degree for a career in the mental health field. By the time I graduate, I will have accumulated over 100k of debt (undergrad + grad). All to enter a much needed field to help people, but also a field that doesn't pay a lot. I will be paying off this debt for the rest of my life. The little bit of help from subsidized loans would have meant a lot to me. I hope that this law is passed to at least help future students.
Like (197)
Follow
Share
Kate's Opinion
···
08/20/2017
I am hearing the claim that decreasing the cost of a degree would over saturate the market and make the degree worthless. However if this is true then it would mean college/graduate degrees are simply an elitist measurement used to keep the poor out of "intellectual" fields. If a degree is truly about knowledge and skill then making it more widely available will ensure the most talented and educated workers.
Like (149)
Follow
Share
Laura's Opinion
···
08/20/2017
Let's make all levels of education more accessible for all!
Like (117)
Follow
Share

Argument opposed

If graduate and professional students want to take out federal students loans they should have to be unsubsidized — taxpayers should only help foot the bill for undergraduate loans.

Will's Opinion
···
08/20/2017
Sure, in an ideal world, but where is the money coming from? The national debt is so obscene, I'd rather not endorse yet another program that can only exist by pinning the bill on my future child's income. Student loans have increased 457% since 2003. The only reason why it is possible for colleges to charge more and more is that the federal government continues to let people borrow more and more. Yet another case where if government just got the fuck out of it, prices would decline. But in my opinion that's not at all what the government wants -- as long as you are in debt to them you are dependent on them, and as long as you are dependent on them they can control you.
Like (33)
Follow
Share
Richard's Opinion
···
08/20/2017
Get the government out of the loan business.
Like (22)
Follow
Share
Richard's Opinion
···
08/20/2017
The reason why college is so expensive is because the government subsidizes the loans and the college know they will get paid so they hack the price up
Like (20)
Follow
Share
    I am currently a grad student getting my masters degree for a career in the mental health field. By the time I graduate, I will have accumulated over 100k of debt (undergrad + grad). All to enter a much needed field to help people, but also a field that doesn't pay a lot. I will be paying off this debt for the rest of my life. The little bit of help from subsidized loans would have meant a lot to me. I hope that this law is passed to at least help future students.
    Like (197)
    Follow
    Share
    Sure, in an ideal world, but where is the money coming from? The national debt is so obscene, I'd rather not endorse yet another program that can only exist by pinning the bill on my future child's income. Student loans have increased 457% since 2003. The only reason why it is possible for colleges to charge more and more is that the federal government continues to let people borrow more and more. Yet another case where if government just got the fuck out of it, prices would decline. But in my opinion that's not at all what the government wants -- as long as you are in debt to them you are dependent on them, and as long as you are dependent on them they can control you.
    Like (33)
    Follow
    Share
    I am hearing the claim that decreasing the cost of a degree would over saturate the market and make the degree worthless. However if this is true then it would mean college/graduate degrees are simply an elitist measurement used to keep the poor out of "intellectual" fields. If a degree is truly about knowledge and skill then making it more widely available will ensure the most talented and educated workers.
    Like (149)
    Follow
    Share
    Let's make all levels of education more accessible for all!
    Like (117)
    Follow
    Share
    Helping those in need achieve a post-secondary degree to build themselves up and position themselves to better serve our economy should be something we can rally behind. No one should be bankrupt from trying to learn.
    Like (61)
    Follow
    Share
    Is this even a question
    Like (39)
    Follow
    Share
    Educated citizenry is always a benefit to the society. Especially if we are hoping to increase the number of STEM workers and begin to import less H1B workers on visa. This used to be available and the fears of problems many "nays" list just weren't happening then. Why would they happen now? Also, student loans do not put the federal government into the loan business. These are bank loans. Just guaranteed by the Fed and interest paid by the Fed until student graduates.
    Like (38)
    Follow
    Share
    Yes, and public undergraduate college should be tuition free... Investing in the education of our citizens is an investment in the future of the US...
    Like (37)
    Follow
    Share
    Our graduate students deserve our support for the work they are putting in to better our society.
    Like (27)
    Follow
    Share
    We must put an emphasis on education in this country. As frightening as it may be for many, (and being middle aged I get it), we will not be going back to those slower what some see as easier times. We will continue to live in this global village. Technology will both virtually and physically put us closer together. We will have to look to science and technology to solve our problems. From Health, to Agriculture, from renewable resources to weapons that can stop but not kill, we will need to train every person to the fullest of their capabilities. We must acknowledge that we are failing so many of our young people and that education can help solve those problems as well. We now know that there are ways to teach our children empathy and compassion at a very young age. We MUST put education at the very top of every political list for the answers are there to find. Yes, we must expand the loans, but we need to revamp our entire educational system to focus on the needs of our country today and the needs of our planet tomorrow.
    Like (23)
    Follow
    Share
    Get the government out of the loan business.
    Like (22)
    Follow
    Share
    The reason why college is so expensive is because the government subsidizes the loans and the college know they will get paid so they hack the price up
    Like (20)
    Follow
    Share
    This question is "Should we make graduate degrees less valuable and more expensive?" When the government subsidizes something, you mess with supply and demand - supply OF people with graduate degrees (but demand for people with graduate degrees is unchanged) and demand FOR spots in graduate degree programs (but supply of spots in graduate programs is unchanged). So the price for a degree goes up and the wage premium justified by that degree in the marketplace drops. Now there are twice as many people with that qualification, but not twice as many jobs. So the qualification isn't as valuable, so even if you do get the job it's harder to pay back that loan than if the government hadn't made your accomplishment less unique. The wage for a graduate degree drops because employers don't have to pay as much of a premium to attract that qualification because it is more common. So you have more people in debt, but no guarantee of more jobs for that higher volume, and the ones who do get jobs will have lower wages. No. Don't do that.
    Like (18)
    Follow
    Share
    The best way to ensure a productive nation is to have educated citizens. Helping those who need financing to get that education makes good sense for our country.
    Like (13)
    Follow
    Share
    Yes please! Grad students should be eligible for Pell Grants as well!
    Like (13)
    Follow
    Share
    Obtaining professional training can take a decade or more after college graduation. Students shouldn't have to work to go to school, they should focus on their professional education. Even so, the cost of living continues to increase, and students must live on whatever they can earn or student loans. They then have to spend the next decades of their lives paying this back, rather than focusing on their profession and work. Having done this for many years myself, this is no way to live, and no way to train the next generation. If we can help these dedicated and ambitious learners - who will become our leaders - by allowing them to get low cost loans, we should.
    Like (12)
    Follow
    Share
    Yes. An investment in educating our youth (or anyone) is an investment in our nation. The more educated a society is the stronger, more successful and stable that society tends to be. I believe undergraduate studies should be free or close to free and subsidized assistance should be available for post-grad students as well. A good education can serve as the great equalizer to lift the marginalized up onto a level playing field. It seems we are trending toward only the wealthy or those willing to assume huge debt being able to receive a college education in the future. This trajectory needs to be disrupted asap both in the interest of social justice and for the future of our economy. A broadly well educated society is among the most effective of checks against tyranny, financial stagnation or decline and social decay. We should all support the education of our citizens. As for where the money will come from, I have a few suggestions. We could appropriately tax the wealthy and corporations. We could stop pouring tax dollars into the pockets of the greedy military industrial complex and the equally greedy and immoral emerging private prison system. We could stop fighting senseless wars that do little beyond cost lives. And we could refrain from throwing tax dollars away on senseless projects like 45's ridiculous wall. I've said "could", but what I meant to say was should. We should do these things. And we should use the freed up tax dollars to support a well educated citizenry.
    Like (12)
    Follow
    Share
    This bill would make it easier for a lot of hard working, dedicated people to advance in their professions when they otherwise could not afford it. It's a good stop gap measure to help the poor and middle class get, and keep getting access to higher learning, until we can make collage (at all levels) freely available to all.
    Like (11)
    Follow
    Share
    The pursuit is noble but not fair when universities profit as much as they do. End the loan programs and reduce the cost of higher education. I will never own a home because of my student debt. I'd been better off stoping after four years despite the fact that I have done pretty well in contributing to my field.
    Like (9)
    Follow
    Share
    The Federal government's subsidization of student loans IS the number one cause of the inflationary prices of college education. Two different Federal Reserves (NY and STL) have independently published extensive reports on the subject. It's also obvious to anyone with even a weak grasp of economics. The government should exit collegiate funding all together if you want to see prices fall within range for more Americans.
    Like (9)
    Follow
    Share
    MORE