Civic Register
| 1.19.22
Senate Rejects Democrats’ Filibuster Reform Plan
How do you feel about the Senate voting to preserve the legislative filibuster?
What’s the story?
- Senate Democrats’ effort to reform the chamber’s legislative filibuster failed Wednesday night, as Republicans and two Democrats voted to oppose the change.
- The matter came to a head after Democrats’ latest election reform proposal ― the Freedom to Vote: John R. Lewis Act ― failed to attain the 60 vote threshold needed to limit debate on a party-line, 50-50 vote. Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) changed his vote to “nay” to give himself the procedural option to bring it up for another vote in the future, making the final margin 49-51.
- Once that vote failed, Schumer and Democrats put forward a proposal to use the Senate’s “nuclear option” to allow the passage of election-related legislation on a simple majority vote after the minority party exhausts a talking filibuster, effectively eliminating the 60 vote threshold for such bills. Because the proposal put forward by Schumer involved a new interpretation of Senate, the presiding chair, Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-VT), ruled it to be out of order, so senators then voted on whether to sustain the chair’s ruling and preserve the filibuster in its current form or to overturn it and create the exception.
- Democrats’ effort to use the nuclear option to create a new exception to the Senate’s legislative filibuster failed on a 52-48 vote, as centrist Sens. Joe Manchin (D-WV) and Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ) joined all Republican senators in voting to uphold the filibuster and oppose the change. Changing the Senate’s precedents using the nuclear option required the support of all 50 Democratic senators plus Vice President Kamala Harris to break the tie.
- More than two dozen Democratic senators who signed onto a bipartisan letter supporting the legislative filibuster in 2017 ― at a time when Republicans controlled the presidency and both chambers of Congress ― reneged on their past pledge and voted in favor of using the nuclear option Wednesday night.
- The Democratic senators who signed the 2017 letter and flip-flopped on the filibuster with Wednesday’s vote were Sens. Michael Bennet (D-CO), Cory Booker (D-NJ), Sherrod Brown (D-OH), Maria Cantwell (D-WA), Tom Carper (D-DE), Bob Casey (D-PA), Chris Coons (D-DE), Tammy Duckworth (D-IL), Dianne Feinstein (D-CA), Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY), Maggie Hassan (D-NH), Martin Heinrich (D-NM), Mazie Hirono (D-HI), Tim Kaine (D-VA), Angus King (I-ME), Amy Klobuchar (D-MN), Patrick Leahy (D-VT), Ed Markey (D-MA), Bob Menendez (D-NJ), Jack Reed (D-RI), Brian Schatz (D-HI), Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Debbie Stabenow (D-MI), Jon Tester (D-MT), Mark Warner (D-VA), and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI).
RELATED READING
- Senate Democrats Deploy ‘Nuclear Option’ for Filibuster Reform Over Elections Bill (1/19/22)
- Biden Urges Senate to Eliminate Filibuster to Clear Way for Democrats’ Election Reforms (1/12/22)
- Schumer Signals Vote on ‘Nuclear Option’ to Eliminate Senate’s Filibuster (1/11/22)
- Manchin Rejects Democrats’ ‘For the People Act’ & Reiterates Support for Preserving Senate’s Filibuster (6/7/21)
- Democrats Flip-Flop on the Filibuster After Winning the Senate Majority (3/30/21)
- Senate Nears Powersharing Deal After Moderate Dems Vow to Preserve Filibuster (1/29/21)
- Should Senate Democrats Eliminate the Legislative Filibuster? (1/25/21)
— Eric Revell
(Photo Credit: iStock.com / Veni)
The Latest
-
IT: Four killed after a shooting at Georgia high school, and... How do you feel about the upcoming election?Welcome to Thursday, September 5th, friends... Four people were killed and at least nine hospitalized after a shooting at a read more...
-
Four Dead and Nine Injured Following Georgia School ShootingIn Barrow County, Ga., four people were killed and at least nine hospitalized after a shooting at Apalachee High School . The read more... Public Safety
-
Election Updates: U.S. Announces Plan To Resist Russian Influence on 2024 ElectionElection Day is 9 weeks away. Here's what's going on in the polls and the presidential candidates' campaigns. September 4, 2024 read more... Congress Shenanigans
-
Florida Whistleblower Leaks Proposal To Pave Over Natural ParksWhat's the story? Florida whistleblower James Gaddis was fired from the state's Department of Environmental Protection for read more... Environment
Thank you for the addresses and thoughts, Kristen! ❤️😊❤️😊. I will get mine in the mail tomorrow!
I support changes to the filibuster. It should not be so easy to filibuster just to obstruct without a legitimate and public argument.
Senators Manchin and Senemen must stop obstruction of the President’s agenda and going against the Democrat Party.
SCOTUS, is back to making law again, the court agrees that only white people should vote. In the south this has been the case for 400 years. What wrong with this; 6 men in black robes decide what races will vote. It’s a disgrace to institution of the Supreme Court!
Thankful that our Missouri Senators voted to keep filibuster rule as is. The process should not change just because one political party has temporary advantage.
States with populations under 5 million people should only get one vote in the Senate. Other states should have their senators vote weighted based on population. That is the only way that what the majority of citizens want ends up to be law. I’m sick of the minority population controlling this country. They don’t represent the views of the majority
Congress has had the tool of the filibuster and its worked great for a century in requiring unity to act. If hostilities are that prevalent within the halls of Congress then clearly some of those members should leave or resign rather than change the responsible rules of operation.
The people of this country need to quit fighting and evolve and so does our government
Time to get rid of outdated and antique fillabuster.
With all the vacation time you guys take all through the calendar year why don't you make it mandatory to pass legislation "for the whole" not just within your States, that will allow bills to pass more quickly through your archaic process so the majority of the Americans will feel it when they need it? It would demonstrate that you do care and you are getting something done.
This should never have been to start with. What ever happened to the "popular vote"? Also, we should be strictly using this method in choosing all candidates!
If you read the Constitution, you'll see as I did that the Constitution doesn't give the Senate the right to have created the Filibuster in the first place. By using the Filibuster, they're actually violating the Constitution. I'm not surprised that the GOP don't want to get rid of it, since it was created after the Civil War and was used as a type of "Jim Crow" way to control changes Congress was making. The GOP are using it now to make Democrats look bad, since the GOP will not pass anything created by Democrats, even if it benefits their constituents!
Ann will not be running this year for reelection. Sinema - I'm glad AZ Democrats have to take action, sadly they can't just get rid of you - traitor!!
Joe manchin for President
Democrats need to reframe the filibuster debate from an argument around subtraction to an argument around addition. Why? People are really really resistant to taking part away, even if it would improve the performance of the whole, but people are much less resistant to the concept of improvement by addition. This would be easy because the filibuster isn't actually a thing to begin with. It is, and has always been, the inappropriate and unintended use of a gap in rules. So the ending of the filibuster is not the removal of a rule, but an addition to the rules that puts a limit on the duration of debate. To imply the filibuster should continue to exist is to assume that the original authors of the senate rules could foresee how such a loophole would be used and intended for it to be used in such a way, which is to imagine that they had a foresight no human has ever possessed in the history of humankind. We actually don't need to talk about the filibuster at all, since it is only empty space in the rulebook anyway. We only need to talk about adding clarification to eliminate unintended loopholes. And as we all know, the people who rely on loopholes to get away things are usually not the cream of the crop, and certainly not the people we want to possess de facto universal veto power.
This filibuster shit needs adjustments or needs to go. It was never meant to be used in the way the Republicans have used it! Manchin and Sinema are a disgrace to their party, their constituents and the rest of our country. All the bullshit is beyond mind blowing. Nothing, not a damn thing is getting done to improve our country! We as a country can not possibly move forward with a minority being in charge instead of the majority. That's assbackwards! That's not how democracy works!
We should not need this. The constant power play by these politicians is crippling this country. We need to send them all home to their respective states and let them only gather on ZOOM. Dismantle DC and let all the career political power people who really run this country in the back ground find another job. We no longer need the DC elite our leaders should all work from home close to those who elected them.
Krysten Sinema has just been censured by the Democratic leaders in Arizona. Kudos to Arizona. Joe Manchin should be censured in his state as well. ENOUGH of the obstruction. ENOUGH of the RED guy in a BLUE suit. ENOUGH of our Democracy being held hostage by the minority.
Democrats desire to do away with long standing tradition should tell you all you need to know about their proposed reforms. They are absolutely political garbage.
It's wonderful to know that the Democrats were able to stand for the basic principles and Senate rules they so strongly favored not more than two years ago.